The coverage you need. The service you deserve.

Our Insurance Agency's Mission

Since 1922, there’s been no better choice for insurance on the coast than McMahon Insurance Agency. Just as you’ve grown to trust us for policies protecting your family, home, health and business, we’ve grown to three locations (Ocean City, Marmora & Cape May) to serve you throughout NJ, PA and DE. We’re proud to say we’ve helped thousands of your neighbors – many over multiple generations – and we look forward to assisting you, too.

Business & Personal Insurance Coverages

Auto

Home

Business

Flood

Life

Condominium

Marine

Group Health

Excess Liability

What Our Clients Say

“

“Because of McMahon’s open communication and outstanding service, I have much more confidence when it comes to my policies, coverages, and most importantly my premiums. My account manager works very hard to make sure I understand every aspect of my policy and for that I am very grateful.”

– Amy Litton, Murphy Fence Co., and Seashore Sheds & Gazebos

“I wanted to give thanks for all the expertise and really nice service that Michael, Bill, and Bonnie have given me over the years. Bonnie has been so patient and helpful. You walked me through the post-Sandy trauma. You guys feel like family.”

– Bill Stuemphfig, Ocean City, NJ

“My uncle highly recommended McMahon Insurance Agency as he has insurance through McMahon for his place in Ocean City. During the process, my condo co-owner, Mark, and I were impressed with McMahon’s knowledge and follow-through. We are happy to be on-board!”

– Joe Schanne, Bryn Mawr, PA

“I was two days away from settlement when I was put in touch with McMahon Insurance. They not only provided me with everything I needed with this purchase, but for my other condo as well! The responsiveness, professionalism, and communication to get this done quickly and efficiently, was outstanding.”

– Dawn B., Philadelphia, PA

“Professional, respectful and willing to work hard to resolve any issue. Showing real concern for you as a person, and not just a customer. Love the McMahon Insurance “shout-outs” on upcoming holiday hours and warnings regarding approaching storms.”

– Birdie Cody, Atlantic City, NJ

“We needed a new condominium insurance policy this year and McMahon was very helpful in getting us several quotes and explaining the differences in what would and what would not be covered.”

– Janice Klemm, Ocean City, NJ

“We had a claim due to a broken pipe and I was impressed that one of the owners came out to help us deal with a repair company that did poor quality work. Then, after Hurricane Sandy, the agency came through for us again.”

– Joel & Kelly McGahen, Waynesboro, PA

“Your help during Sandy was absolutely terrific. I can’t imagine getting better service. You have our business and we have no reason to even consider changing agencies!”

– Ted and Jean Robb, Asbury Avenue Condominium Association, Ocean City, NJ

“My parents were long-time McMahon Insurance clients who recommended the agency to us. We’ve been with you for over 25 years, and appreciate your family approach, many services, and knowledgeable and friendly employees.”

– Michele & Thomas Barbieri, Seaville, NJ

“Mr. McMahon himself took the time to personally meet with me during the immediate aftermath of Hurricane Sandy to explain my coverage and the process for submitting my claim. His assistance and compassion during this difficult time was much appreciated.”

– Barry Bloom, Poughkeepsie, NY

“We had a big claim in 2015, and McMahon Insurance was most helpful getting us in touch with the right folks. We also bought a new home that year, and they found us the best coverage for our needs at the best price.”

What kind of insurance are you looking for?