ABOUT US

Why McMahon Insurance Agency?


Founded in 1922, McMahon Insurance brings to you nearly 100 years of success in meeting insurance needs and delivering satisfaction.

Advantages

In addition to our extensive experience, here are five more advantages to choosing us:

Superior Customer Service

Unlike others, we won’t simply refer you to an 800 number. Call us instead at 609-399-0060 at any time 24/7/365 and we’ll take full ownership of your claim.

Flood Expertise

Many national insurers and local agencies shy away from flood insurance. Not us. In fact, we’re honored to have been named National Flood Insurance Program Agent of the Year.

Better Pricing

We’re fully independent. So we can shop your coverage needs to any of over 35 top-rated underwriters to help find the best value for you.

Tri-State Convenience

We regularly write policies for home and business owners throughout New Jersey, Pennsylvania and Delaware.

Fast Results

We’ve gotten to know most local contractors, mortgage lenders and real estate agents. Should any concerns on insurance surface, we can quickly resolve them on your behalf.

Our Team

Meeting your needs – and exceeding your expectations – for nearly a century.

The McMahon Insurance Agency can trace its roots to 1922 as Haney Lloyd Chattin Real Estate & Insurance. In the 1960s, Albert Halliday purchased the firm and it became the Chattin-Halliday Agency. In 1981, Bill McMahon, Jr. bought the business and began operating with two employees and one office. In 1991, we became McMahon Insurance. Over the years, we have grown to serve our clients from four locations and with 64 employees.

Maintaining McMahon’s legacy of superior service is a team that includes the following dedicated professionals.

Bill McMahon, III

Bill McMahon III

President
(609) 736-4059
BillM@mcmahonagency.com

Maura McMahon Primus

Maura McMahon Primus

Vice President
(609) 736-4060
MauraP@mcmahonagency.com

Michael P. McMahon

Michael P. McMahon

Claims Manager
(609) 770-8786
michaelm@mcmahonagency.com

Patrick McMahon

Patrick McMahon

Commercial Lines Manager
(609) 736-4048
PatrickM@mcmahonagency.com

Brian McMahon

Brian McMahon

Chief Operations Officer
(609) 789-5574
BrianM@mcmahonagency.com

Andrew Halliday

Andrew Halliday

Account Executive
(609) 736-4042
Andrew@mcmahonagency.com

Angela-Wolfe

Angela Wolfe

Branch Office Manager
(609) 798-0481
AngelaW@mcmahonagency.com

JoAnn-Venditto

JoAnn Venditto

Condominium Department Manager
(609) 736-4007
JoAnnV@mcmahonagency.com

Joan Adams

Joan Adams

Condominium Account Manager
(609) 736-4014
JoanA@mcmahonagency.com

Bonnie Ash 2024

Bonnie Ash

Personal Lines Account Manager
(609) 736-4335
BonnieA@mcmahonagency.com

Katherine Atohi

Katherine Komis

Personal Lines Technician
(609) 798-1179
KatieK@mcmahonagency.com

Michelle Bishop - Headshot (Circle)

Michelle Bishop

Condominium Account Manager
(609) 736-4084
MBishop@mcmahonagency.com

Darleen Bonner

Darleen Bonner

Personal Lines Account Manager
(609) 736-4002
DarleenB@mcmahonagency.com

Betsy Brown

Betsy Brown

Personal Lines Technician
(609) 798-0483
BetsyB@mcmahonagency.com

Susan Coulter

Receptionist
(609) 736-4066
SueC@mcmahonagency.com

Denise Crain

Personal Lines Account Manager
(609) 789-5561
DeniseC@mcmahonagency.com

Dolores Cripps

Commercial Lines Specialist
(609) 789-5527
DoloresC@mcmahonagency.com

Brian Deo

Brian Deo

Commercial Lines Technician
(609) 597-8509
BrianD@mcmahonagency.com

Renee Deo

Condominium Account Manager
(609) 597-8509
ReneeD@mcmahonagency.com

Debbie Dworkin

Personal Lines Manager
(609) 789-5526
DebbieD@mcmahonagency.com

Kelly Fabrizio

Kelly Fabrizio

Commercial Lines
609-736-4078
kellyf@mcmahonagency.com

Amylyn Fessler

Systems Specialist
(609) 789-5539
AmylynF@mcmahonagency.com

Mark Grampp

Mark Grampp

Personal Lines Account Manager
(609) 798-1061
MarkG@mcmahonagency.com

Devin Gray

Devin Gray

Personal Lines Technician
(609) 789-5542
DevinG@mcmahonagency.com

Marilyn Groom

Personal Lines Technician
(609) 789-5533
MarilynG@mcmahonagency.com

Krista Hansen

Commercial Lines Account Manager
(609) 736-4012
KristaH@mcmahonagency.com

Christine Karl

Christine Karl

Personal Lines Account Manager
(609) 789-5537
Christinek@mcmahonagency.com

Barb Kiel

Barbara Kiel

Commercial Lines Account Manager
(609) 736-4028
BarbaraK@mcmahonagency.com

Carmen LoVerde

Personal Lines Account Manager
(609) 789-5541
CarmenL@mcmahonagency.com

mcmahon logo

Michele Marra

Personal Lines Account Manager
(609) 789-5577
MMarra@mcmahonagency.com

Ryan McCabe

Branch Director
(609) 789-5524
RyanM@mcmahonagency.com

Bonnie McIlvaine

Personal Lines Technician
BonnieM@mcmahonagency.com

Angelina Meros

Angelina Meros

Commercial Lines Technician
(609) 789-5565
AngelinaM@mcmahonagency.com

Michael Meros

Commercial Lines Marketing
(609) 789-5531
MMeros@mcmahonagency.com

Claudia Miller

Claudia Miller

Commercial Lines Account Manager
(609) 798-1071
ClaudiaM@mcmahonagency.com

Briana Mitchell

Briana Mitchell

Director of Technology
(609) 736-4065
Bmitchell@mcmahonagency.com

Amber O’Neill

Personal Lines Account Manager
(609) 789-5536
AmberO@mcmahonagency.com

BJ-OConnell

BJ O’Connell

Condominium Account Manager
(609) 798-0484
BJO@mcmahonagency.com

Suzie Paisley

Receptionist
(609) 736-4067
SusanP@mcmahonagency.com

Linda Peruto

Linda Peruto

Accounting
(609) 736-4075
LindaP@mcmahonagency.com

Pamela-Peterson

Pam Peterson

Personal Lines Account Manager
(609) 798-1064
PamelaP@mcmahonagency.com

Patti Potterton

Personal Lines Technician
(609) 789-5538
PattiP@mcmahonagency.com

mcmahon logo

Marie Pozalante

Personal Lines Account Manager
(609) 789-5535
MarieP@mcmahonagency.com

Tricia Pelehach

Tricia Pelehach

Commercial Lines Account Manager
(609) 789-5530
TriciaP@mcmahonagency.com

Patricia Reilly

Commercial Lines Account Manager
(609) 789-5571
PatriciaR@mcmahonagency.com

Kara Reilley

Kara Reilley

Condominium Account Manager
(609) 736-4016
KaraR@mcmahonagency.com

Brandee Ritter 2024

Brandee Ritter

Personal Lines Account Manager
(609) 736-4033
BrandeeR@mcmahonagency.com

Isabel Saxer-Dasti

Personal Lines Account Manager
(609) 789-5572
Isabel@mcmahonagency.com

Beth-Skversky

Beth Skversky

Condominium Technician
(609) 736-4011
Beth@mcmahonagency.com

Connie Souza

Personal Lines Technician
(609) 789-5578
ConnieS@mcmahonagency.com

Lynne-Tomasello

Lynne Tomasello

Personal Lines Account Manager
(609) 736-4074
LynneT@mcmahonagency.com

mcmahon logo

Yvonne Torres

Personal Lines Account Manager
(609) 736-4115
YvonneT@mcmahonagency.com

2024 Michele Trimmer

Michele Trimmer

Commercial Lines Account Manager
(609) 736-4013
MicheleT@mcmahonagency.com

mcmahon logo

Pat Tyson

Condominium Account Manager
(609) 736-4017
PatT@mcmahonagency.com

2024 Kathleen Ward

Kathleen Ward

Personal Lines Account Manager
(609) 798-1173
KathleenW@mcmahonagency.com

Peggy-Weir

Peggy Weir

Commercial Lines Account Manager
(609) 798-1167
PeggyW@mcmahonagency.com

Nancy-Williams

Nancy Williams

Commercial Lines Technician
(609) 736-4036
NancyW@mcmahonagency.com

Scott-Williams

Scott Williams

Account Executive
(609) 736-4045
ScottW@mcmahonagency.com

mcmahon logo

Catherine (Katie) Wolak

Condominium Account Manager
(609) 597-8508
CatherineW@mcmahonagency.com

Welcome to McMahon Insurance Agency!

On behalf of the entire McMahon Insurance Agency, we’d like to take this opportunity to welcome you. At McMahon Insurance, we pride ourselves on offering our customers responsive and excellent service. Our customers are the most important part of our business, and we work tirelessly to ensure your complete satisfaction. Thank you for entrusting McMahon Insurance with your most important coverage needs. We are honored to serve you.

We would like to take you on a quick tour of our agency in our new location at 901 Simpson Avenue.

Sincerely,

Bill McMahon III, Maura McMahon Primus, Michael McMahon, Patrick McMahon, and Brian McMahon

Seeking great people to join our team

Want to join our talented team? McMahon Insurance is a leading provider of property casualty insurance for auto, home, and business. Our success is built upon our ability to provide innovative insurance and risk protection products and services that meet our customers’ needs. We pride ourselves on helping customers manage risk before a claim occurs and responding with speed, professionalism and compassion when claims do happen.

McMahon Insurance Agency has operations in Manahawkin, Marmora, Cape May, and Ocean City, New Jersey and offers its customers a wide range of coverages as well as specialized risk control services to help individuals and business owners protect against the unexpected. McMahon Insurance Agency is an Equal Opportunity Employer.

The coverage you need.

sun icon

The service you deserve.