Report a Claim

Responding to your requests 24 hours a day, 7 days a week at 609-399-0060

While you never want to experience a loss, McMahon Insurance is ready to provide direction and assistance from the time you report claim until a satisfactory resolution is achieved.

Our claim service begins immediately after we receive your report when we notify the insurance carrier to expedite the claim. We work for you throughout the entire process and are here to answer any questions and help ensure you have a satisfactory resolution to your claim.

While most claims are routinely addressed, if during the course of process you have any special questions or concerns, please contact Michael McMahon, Claims Manager, at 609-399-0060 ext. 310 or at michaelm@mcmahonagency.com.

 

Before calling about a claim, be sure to have this information ready:

  • Name of Insured
  • Best Phone number to contact you
  • Date of Loss
  • Location of Loss
  • Description of Damage

 

Prefer to report the claim directly to the insurer?

These companies have 24/7 claims call centers and/or online claim reporting options if you would like to work with them.

americanModernUpdated

American Modern

800-375-2075

Chubb

Chubb Group of Insurance Companies

800-252-4670

 
Cumberland INsurance Group

Cumberland Insurance Group

800-232-6992
For emergency claims requiring immediate attention occurring during evenings, weekends or holidays.
Online Claims Reporting

Emcompas Insurance

Encompass

800-588-7400
Claims Service

 
Farmers Insurance of Flemington

Farmers of Flemington

866-631-9153 (for service after normal business hours)
Online Form to Report claim

Farmer's Mutual Fire Insurance Company of Salem County

Farmers of Salem

Online Claims Reporting

Foremost INsurance

Foremost Insurance

800-527-3907
Online Form to Report Claim

 
FMI_LogoNoTagline

Franklin Mutual Insurance Company

Webpage with forms to report claims

Harleysville-Nationwide-logo

Harleysville/Nationwide

800-421-3535
800-421-3535 (flood claims)
Online Form to Report Claim

Merchants Insurance Group insurance provider

Merchants Insurance Group

800-322-8608
888-644-6680 (for service after normal business hours)
Online Claims Reporting

 
MetLife Insurance Company PRovider

MetLife

800-854-6011

Narragansett Bay Insurance

Narragansett Bay Insurance Company

800-343-3375, option 2
Online Claims Reporting

Liberty Mutual Logo

Peerless/Liberty Mutual

800-522-7152

 
Penn National Insurance Company Provider

Penn National

800-766-2245, option 2, then press 1
800-766-2245 (Worker’s Comp Workplace Injury claims)
Online Claim Reporting

Palisades Insurance Company Provider

Plymouth Rock (Palisades)

877-PAL-NICE

PReferred Mutual Insurance Company Provier

Preferred Mutual Insurance Company

800-333-7642
Online Claim Reporting

 
Progressive Auto Insurance PRovider

Progressive

800-274-4499
800-PROGRESSIVE

Selective Response Provider

Selective

866-455-9969
877-348-0552 (flood claims)
Online Claim Reporting

The Hartford Insurance Group Provider

The Hartford

800-243-5860 (Homeowners & Personal Auto claims)
800-327-3636 (Commercial Auto, Business & Liability claims)

 
Travelers Insurance Group Provider

Travelers

800-252-4633
800-238-6225 (Commercial Auto, Property, General Liability, Specialty & Workers Comp claims)
Online Claims Center

The coverage you need.

sun-icon

The service you deserve.