Important Update on Kingstone Insurance Company’s Exit from New Jersey

What’s Happening:

  • Kingstone Insurance Company is leaving the New Jersey market effective January 2024.

Notifications You’ll Receive:

  1. Initial Notification: Expect a letter from Kingstone in the next week informing you of this change.
  2. Nonrenewal Notice: 60 days before your policy expires, Kingstone will send you a notice saying they won’t renew your policy.

What McMahon Is Doing:

  • Proactive Measures: We anticipated this move and have been switching our customers to new carriers as policies come up for renewal.
  • Replacement Plans: Your McMahon representative will contact you about 60 days before your policy renews to provide a new coverage option.

What You Need to Do:

  • No Immediate Action Needed: You don’t have to do anything right now. Just know that we’re taking care of this for you.


  • Contact Us: If you have any concerns or questions, please reach out to us. We’re here to help!