Meet Our Team Old

Meeting your needs – and exceeding your expectations – for nearly a century

The McMahon Insurance Agency can trace its roots to 1922 as Haney Lloyd Chattin Real Estate & Insurance. In the 1960s, Albert Halliday purchased the firm and it became the Chattin-Halliday Agency. In 1981, Bill McMahon, Jr. bought the business and began operating with two employees and one office. In 1991, we became McMahon Insurance. Over the years, we have grown to serve our clients from two locations and with over 35 employees.

Since day one, we’ve been organization dedicated to our community through our extensive involvement in it, and to our customers. We realize the priceless value of service, whether it is in response to an insurance claim or general question. As our president, Bill McMahon III believes, “Without quality customer service, insurance is just an expensive piece of paper.”

Maintaining McMahon’s legacy of superior service is a team that includes:







William J. McMahon III

President







Maura McMahon Primus

Vice President & CFO







Michael McMahon

Claims Manager







Patrick McMahon

Sales Coordinator







Brian McMahon

Account Manager







Joan Adams

Condominium Account Manager







Bonnie Ash

Account Manager







Darleen Bonner

Customer Service Representative







Betsy Brown

Personal Lines Technician







Jake Cassidy

Personal Lines Account Manager







Susan Coulter







Beth Crowther

Personal Lines Producer







Zachary Eberson

Account Executive







Eileen Golas

Condominium Account Manager







Mark Grampp

Account Manager







Andrew Halliday

Sales Manager







Steacy Hartman

Commercial Lines Technician







Barbara Kiel

Account Manager







Claudia Miller

Account Manager







Briana Mitchell







Barbara Muller

Commercial Lines Technician







B.J. O’Connell

Account Manager







Dennis Padick

Account Manager







Suzie Paisley

Receptionist







Pamela Peterson

Account Manager







Michael Razze

Commercial Lines Manager







Kara Reilley

Customer Service Representative







Brandee Ritter

Account Manager







Christina Scarborough

Customer Service Representative







Terence Sikoryak

Financial Services
& Employee Benefits Manager







Beth Skversky

Technician







Lynne Tomasello

Account Manager







Debbie Townsend

Bookkeeper







Pat Tyson

Customer Service Representative







JoAnn Venditto

Condominium Department Manager







Peggy Weir

Account Manager







Scott Williams

Account Executive







Angela Wolfe

Office Manager







Nancy Williams

Commercial Lines Technician