Insurance Agency in Cape May, NJ
Protect Your Cape May Home and Business Today
From Beach Avenue to the Washington Street Mall, McMahon Insurance helps Cape May homeowners, renters, and business owners stay protected year-round. Our tailored policies for coastal living include homeowners, flood, auto, and business insurance—built for Cape May’s historic charm and seaside resilience.
Cape May, NJ Insurance
Cape May blends Victorian architecture, thriving tourism, and coastal weather patterns that require careful planning when it comes to insurance. Whether you own a classic home near the historic district, manage a rental property, or run a local business, McMahon Insurance offers comprehensive coverage to safeguard what matters most.
Coverage That Fits Cape May Living
Living and working in Cape May means protecting against coastal flooding, storm damage, and seasonal rental risks. McMahon Insurance provides flexible solutions for homeowners, vacation properties, vehicles, and businesses—ensuring you’re covered through every season on the Jersey Shore.
Why Cape May Chooses McMahon
For generations, Cape May residents have trusted McMahon Insurance for reliable, personal service. As a local, family-owned agency, we understand coastal challenges and offer competitive rates through leading carriers. Our goal is to keep your coverage simple, transparent, and ready when you need it most.
FAQs
Do you offer insurance for historic homes in Cape May?
Yes, we specialize in coverage for older and historic homes, helping preserve their value while protecting against modern risks.
Can I get flood insurance if I’m not in a high-risk zone?
Absolutely. Flooding can occur anywhere in Cape May, and we can help you find affordable coverage through private carriers or the National Flood Insurance Program.
Does McMahon cover seasonal rental properties?
Yes, we provide landlord and short-term rental policies that protect your property, income, and liability during the busy tourist season.
McMahon Insurance Agency makes Cape May insurance simple—home, auto, flood, and business coverage done right.
The coverage you need. The service you deserve.
Our Mission
Since 1922, there’s been no better choice for insurance on the coast than McMahon Insurance. And just as you’ve grown to trust us for policies protecting your family, home, health and business, we’ve grown to serve you throughout New Jersey, Pennsylvania and Delaware. We’re proud to say we’ve helped thousands of your neighbors – many over multiple generations – and we look forward to assisting you, too.
Our Coverage
What Our Clients Say
